Orange Creamsicle Pie

What the heck is this?

So last summer I was hit with this mega nostalgic craving for those orange creamsicles from the ice cream truck – you know, the ones with the vanilla ice cream inside and the orange popsicle outside? I was also supposed to bring a dessert to my friend’s cookout the next day, and I thought, “Why not turn that flavor into a pie?” After a few tries (and one spectacular failure that we don’t talk about), this Orange Creamsicle Pie was born. It’s creamy, dreamy, with that perfect balance of tangy orange and mellow vanilla that takes you straight back to childhood summers, but in a grown-up form that’ll make everyone at the table think you’re some kind of dessert wizard.

Why You’ll Love This Recipe

Listen, this isn’t just another pie recipe:

• It tastes EXACTLY like those orange creamsicle pops from your childhood, but better because, hello, it’s pie.
• The texture is ridiculous – like a cloud of orange-vanilla heaven that melts in your mouth.
• It’s the perfect balance of sweet and tangy (nobody wants a pie that makes your teeth hurt from sweetness).
• You can make it ahead of time, which means less day-of stress when you’re hosting.
• It’s a total showstopper but is actually pretty foolproof to make.
• It’s refreshing as heck for summer but weirdly satisfying in winter too (vitamin C, am I right?).
• Even your weird uncle who “doesn’t like fruity desserts” will be coming back for seconds.

The Good Stuff You’ll Need

For the Crust:

• 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs (about 10 full sheets, pulverized) (vanilla wafers work too)
• 1/4 cup sugar (white or brown, I’m not the boss of you)
• Pinch of salt (don’t skip this, it makes the sweet stuff taste better)
• 6 tablespoons butter, melted (salted or unsalted, whatever’s in your fridge)
• Optional: 1 tablespoon orange zest (if you’re feeling extra)

For the Filling:

• 1 cup fresh orange juice (please, for the love of all things holy, squeeze it yourself)
• Zest from 2 oranges (before you juice them, obviously)
• 1 can (14 oz) sweetened condensed milk (the full-fat stuff, this isn’t the time for dieting)
• 8 oz cream cheese, softened (leave it out for at least an hour)
• 1 cup heavy whipping cream
• 1/4 cup powdered sugar
• 2 teaspoons vanilla extract (the real kind, not that imitation nonsense)
• 1 package (3 oz) orange-flavored gelatin (yes, the one that rhymes with “hello”)
• 1/4 cup boiling water
• Optional: 2-3 drops orange food coloring (if you want that vibrant orange look)

For the Topping:

• 1 cup heavy whipping cream
• 1/4 cup powdered sugar
• 1 teaspoon vanilla extract
• Orange slices for garnish (candied if you’re fancy, fresh if you’re not)
• Optional: orange zest for sprinkling

PIN IT

Let’s Do This

Make the Crust (10 minutes):

1. Preheat your oven to 350°F. I know, using the oven in summer can be a pain, but it’s just for 10 minutes, I promise.
2. Crush your graham crackers into oblivion. You can use a food processor, or put them in a zip-top bag and take out some aggression with a rolling pin.
3. Mix the crumbs with sugar, salt, and orange zest (if using). Pour in the melted butter and mix until it looks like wet sand. If it seems too dry, add another tablespoon of butter.
4. Press this mixture into a 9-inch pie plate. I use the bottom of a measuring cup to really pack it in there. Make sure to go up the sides too.
5. Bake for 8-10 minutes until it’s just starting to get a little color and smells amazing. Let it cool completely while you make the filling.

Make the Filling (20 minutes + chill time):

1. In a small bowl, mix the orange gelatin with 1/4 cup boiling water, stirring until completely dissolved. Set aside to cool slightly (but don’t let it set).
2. In a large bowl, beat the cream cheese until smooth and fluffy. Seriously, make sure there are NO lumps or you’ll have little cream cheese bombs in your smooth pie.
3. Gradually add in the sweetened condensed milk, beating until well combined. Then mix in the orange juice, orange zest, and the dissolved gelatin mixture. If using food coloring, add it now.
4. In a separate bowl, whip the heavy cream with the powdered sugar and vanilla until stiff peaks form. You’re looking for the point where when you lift the beaters, the cream stands up and just barely curls over at the tip.
5. Gently fold the whipped cream into the orange mixture. Take your time here – you want to maintain as much air as possible while still fully incorporating everything.
6. Pour this beautiful orange cloud into your cooled crust. Smooth the top with a spatula.
7. Refrigerate for AT LEAST 4 hours, but overnight is even better. The waiting is the hardest part, but I believe in you.

Make the Topping (5 minutes):

1. Just before serving, whip the remaining cup of heavy cream with the powdered sugar and vanilla until stiff peaks form.
2. You can either spread this over the entire pie or pipe it decoratively around the edges. If you’re not into fancy piping, just dollop it on top – it’ll still taste amazing.
3. Garnish with orange slices and a sprinkle of orange zest if you’re feeling fancy.

The Big Moment:

When you slice into this pie, you’ll get this gorgeous creamy orange filling that holds its shape but is still lusciously soft. Snap a pic for the ‘gram before it disappears, because it will disappear FAST.

Serving Suggestions

• For ultimate summer vibes, serve with a tiny paper umbrella stuck in each slice. Instant vacation feels.
• A drizzle of white chocolate on the plate before you set down the slice makes it look restaurant-fancy.
• This pairs surprisingly well with iced coffee or even better, a scoop of vanilla bean ice cream on the side (yes, I know that’s dessert on dessert, and no, I don’t see a problem with that).
• If you’re serving at a party, pre-slice and put each piece on a separate plate topped with whipped cream and garnish. People are always impressed by pre-plated desserts.
• For a boozy adult version, serve with a shot of vanilla vodka on the side. Don’t judge me until you’ve tried it.

Switch It Up

Got the basics down but want to experiment? Try these variations:

• The Chocolate Twist: Add a layer of chocolate ganache on top of the crust before pouring in the filling. Orange and chocolate are besties.
• The Coconut Dream: Use coconut cream instead of heavy cream in the filling and add toasted coconut to the crust. Hello, tropical paradise.
• The Raspberry Ripple: Swirl some raspberry puree through the filling before chilling. The sweet-tart combo is mind-blowing.
• The Boozy Version: Add 2 tablespoons of Grand Marnier or Triple Sec to the filling. I won’t tell if you won’t.
• The Shortcut: Use a store-bought graham cracker crust and instant vanilla pudding mixed with orange juice, fold in Cool Whip, and chill. Not quite the same but still darn good in a pinch.
• The Frozen: Freeze the whole pie for a few hours for more of an ice cream pie vibe. Just let it sit at room temp for about 10 minutes before serving or you’ll need a chainsaw to cut it.

Storage Tips

• This pie will keep in the refrigerator for up to 3 days. Cover it with plastic wrap after the first cut to prevent it from drying out.
• For the best texture, add the whipped cream topping right before serving, not in advance.
• This pie doesn’t freeze particularly well (the texture gets weird), so I recommend making it within a few days of when you plan to serve it.
• If you have leftover slices (ha, as if), store them in airtight containers in the fridge. The crust might get a little soft, but it’ll still taste amazing.

PIN IT

Questions People Actually Ask

Q: Can I use bottled orange juice instead of fresh?
A: I mean, you CAN, but we won’t be friends anymore. Bottled juice lacks the bright flavor of fresh and often has a weird aftertaste. If you absolutely must, get the not-from-concentrate kind at minimum.

Q: Do I really need to let the cream cheese come to room temperature?
A: Unless you enjoy arm cramps from trying to beat cold cream cheese and finding random lumps in your smooth pie, then yes, you absolutely do. Plan ahead, people!

Q: Can I make this with other citrus fruits?
A: Heck yes! Try it with lemons (use lemon gelatin), limes (lime gelatin), or even grapefruit (use orange gelatin and adjust sugar if needed). Just keep the juice-to-condensed milk ratio the same.

Q: My gelatin started setting before I could mix it into the filling. Now what?
A: Microwave it for 10 seconds and stir again. Crisis averted.

Q: I don’t have a stand mixer or hand mixer. Can I still make this?
A: You’re in for a serious arm workout, but yes. Use room temperature ingredients and a whole lot of elbow grease with a whisk. The whipped cream will be the biggest challenge – put your bowl and whisk in the freezer first to help things along.

Q: My pie didn’t set properly and is too soft. What went wrong?
A: Most likely culprits: you didn’t let the gelatin dissolve completely, you didn’t chill it long enough, or the ratio of liquid to gelatin was off. Make sure to measure carefully and give it at least 4 hours (preferably overnight) in the fridge.

Print